Team GotQuestions Blog

a Blog for Sharing Stories, Tips & Encouragement

Encouragement from the GQ team when God seems silent

November 13th, 2015

It seems that I have not been appointed to stay here with GQ ministries and that is okay, since it is God’s prerogative. I have had a wonderful 11 months here with all of you and I wish you continued success in your ministry.

As for me, I truly believe God has abandoned me. It is not a sudden feeling, it gradually came on over the past 3 years. I know many of you will say “that he never leaves his people” which I guess is true but it means that I probably was never one of his people. The problem is that I have prayed and believed, truly believed. It will take a miracle from him to accuse me on the day of Judgement for not believing. Like every good Christian, I prayed every day, read my bible and sought a personal relationship with him. I wanted so much to please him (that was the reason I started here). I remember one time after I had sinned greatly feeling such agonizing despair that I cried because I had offended God and vowed never to let it happen again. That was the extent of my faith. In fact, I use to consult him about everything, from mundane events like finding a parking space or helping me to pass an exam to big events like what I should say to witness most effectively to others.

I have prayed about this particular situation and even requested your petitions, yet all requests have been in vain. If I was “in the world” I truly believe that he would helped, since he seems to help those kind of people frequently. Quite frankly I am tired of him saying “no” and “wait”.
I have lived for God for 3 years of my life (not long I know), read countless books, asked questions and complied many different articles. I have never been drunk, had sex, taken drugs, went to a party (strip club etc.) or engaged in any of the defining sins of my generation (21). All of this because, at one point, I truly believed that he was my Father and who doesn’t want to please their Father?. One time, a girl gave me an ultimatum, either fornicate with her or our relationship would be over. I remember that I was so excited because I thought that God was testing me. Immediately, I proceeded to tell her that our relationship was over and I was actually happy because I had passed the test.

Fast forward to present day, I am convinced that he intends to destroy my faith. I am not exaggerating when I say that he does not answer even one single prayer. He doesn’t! Well at least not for me. Maybe for his ‘super elect’ he does.

There are situations in my life which have persisted for as long as I can remember but I never complained about them before. I remember praying to God before I was even a Christian. Every morning on the school bus I would talk to him and I thought that maybe this was the purpose I was raised for, to become a Christian. It seems I was wrong and that I instead serve another unknown purpose.

I do not care to suffer now for eternal rewards. I rather have no eternal rewards and these situations end. They have gone on for too long but I guess the Lord prefers not to stop them. Much like how he prefers not to stop evil acts or sin.

I have developed a saying which encapsulates how I feel perfectly. “Nothing good appointed, nothing good expected, no disappointments at all.” It means that before the foundation of the world, the LORD, when he was conceiving all things, decided to appoint nothing good for my life, as such, I should never expect anything good to occur and then I will never be disappointed by the inevitable bad that will occur.

I question the very notion that God is indeed good. How can this be so? He seems to prefer to bring about evil situations rather than good ones.

I will say that I truly believe that God the Father, Jesus Christ and the Holy Spirit exist as the one triune God of the universe. However, I do not believe that he has any intention of ever helping me overcome my problems, he can attest to that himself on the day of Judgement. In this world, there is entirely too much evil which he allows to go unchecked. Furthermore, he seems to have a “class” system concerning his elect. I have watched other Christians go on and be successful all too often. I know that I follow him and I shouldn’t be envious of others because it shows that I don’t think he is generous with his gifts. The truth is, I no longer believe that he is generous, actually my thinking more closely reflects those in Malachi 2:17 and 3:13-18.

I didn’t think that I could be brought to tears easily, but over the course of the past few years and constantly crying out to God to be ignored I know what it feels like to shed genuine tears for the faith. My eyes are watering as I write this, because in the deep recesses of my mind I do want him to be good, loving and caring (to me). I want him to be the Jesus Christ of the bible not the distant god of today. I longed for God to show up to me and prove me wrong like he did with Job, Asaph or Habakkuk but I fear I wait in vain.

I have stopped praying completely because it is exactly like leaving a message at the tone.

Continue to pray for me if you so desire. I will always be thankful to all of you and I hope to see you guys one day on the right side of eternity.

I now understand why so many people will follow the Anti-Christ and take the mark of the beast. You see, it is exactly because that my situation is all too common amongst Christians. So many are constantly let down by him that when the AC is finally revealed he will be the answer to so many of these problems that people will leave the faith and follow him.

Unmet expectations destroy faith. I am not talking about God making me have no problems, I simply mean that less would be better in this case. However, I realize that he will never answer me on this side of eternity he much rather continue to treat me like a fool in all his ways.

Honestly, I wish the thought of creating me had never entered his mind from before the foundation of the world.

Comments
Ed Romero
Ed Romero Kris, it took a lot of courage to share this. I’m praying for you, and I also sent you a message in case you’d like to share some more

Like · Reply · 7 · 19 hrs

Laurel J. Davis
Laurel J. Davis I wish I had the magic words to encourage your spirit. Just know, for what it’s worth, that I care. I also know you are not alone in how you feel.

Like · Reply · 5 · 19 hrs
Tim White
Tim White Kris, all of us have been where you are, to some degree or the other. Yes, I will be praying for you. It may not be applicable, but when I was there, it was later clear, perfectly clear, that my expectations were for this life. Since I missed the entire concept that this vapor of a life is to be lived by faith (no evidence, no answers) in preparation for the real life, I felt that everyone else had a “real” relationship, with real protection and real fellowship with God, but I was left out. I may feel like that again. However, I am learning, slowly but slowly, that this faith-life is not about the here and now. No evidence, no proof, no answers, no guarantee of relief. God said it. I have to believe it. I will have not expectation of answers or relief in this life. That, for now, is fine with me. I hope you find peace.

Like · Reply · 8 · 19 hrs
Laurel J. Davis
Laurel J. Davis Brother Tim, for my own benefit as well as Kris’, can you share a verse or passage – esp. for the part where you say, “No evidence, no proof, no answers, no guarantee of relief. God said it.” That would be very helpful. Thank you very much.

Like · Reply · 1 · 19 hrs
Tim White
Tim White The low hanging fruit is Hebrews 11. The entire passage. But for brevity, “Now faith is the assurance of things hoped for, the conviction of things not seen.” Then the Bible is packed with people being tested by being expected to believe and act in this like what God said it true, but the entire world screaming that its not. Hebrews 11:36-40, ““Others suffered mocking and flogging, and even chains and imprisonment. They were stoned, they were sawn in two, they were killed with the sword. They went about in skins of sheep and goats, destitute, afflicted, mistreated—of whom the world was not worthy—wandering about in deserts and mountains, and in dens and caves of the earth. And all these, though commended through their faith, did not receive what was promised, since God had provided something better for us, that apart from us they should not be made perfect.”

Like · Reply · 3 · 19 hrs
Laurel J. Davis
Laurel J. Davis Beautiful. Thanks again.

Gwen Sellers

Write a reply…
 
Dale Agner
Dale Agner Kris, thanks for sharing…life is often (usually) what we do not expect it to be. Happy to discuss more, if desired. I often use a flying analogy of the 5Cs, which you are doing some now. When lost as a pilot, we are to climb to get a visual perspective of where we are, Confess to ourselves and air traffic control that we are lost, Communicate with others, Conserve fuel, Comply with what ATC tells me to do…..I have used a spiritual analogy, for which I have had to use myself… you are doing several already..communicate with others, which you are doing, confess that I am lost, which you are doing (sometimes this means confessing something awkward to a close friend), conserve energy (get sleep, don’t take myself seriously when I am burned out), comply….for this I talk to a trusted friend, and follow his advice, climb (get perspective….sometimes this means getting away from the bustle…the book “Disappointment with God” by Yancey comes to mind….today when things felt dry…I just read the proverb that matched the date, and a psalm that corresponded with the date…life is an interesting intersection of physical and spiritual…praying for you brother!

Like · Reply · 7 · 19 hrs
Robert Lowry
Robert Lowry Kris, this is so distressing to hear. Please do this. Read Psalm 88. It sounds like you could have written that Psalm. In my Bible it’s headlined “Crying from Deepest Affliction”. But then read Psalm 107. It’s headlined “God Satisfies the Longing Soul”. I pray that it lifts you out of the depth of despair you are in and brings you back to God’s loving arms.

Like · Reply · 7 · 19 hrs
Deb Whittier Newman
Deb Whittier Newman Kris, I’m sorry. I too was in your shoes in my 20s. I found Christ in my 40s; truly found Him. He IS there. He DOES love you. The thing that I had to come to see was that He doesn’t HAVE to show us anything. He is God. But please, never doubt His love because there was blood shed to show the depth of His love. I’ll definitely add you to my prayer list. God bless you.

Like · Reply · 6 · 18 hrs
Laurel J. Davis
Laurel J. Davis Kris, I meant to ask, and if you feel like sharing here, what do you plan to do with your life and walk from this point going forward? You seem fairly resolved, but do you have a plan you want to share?

Like · Reply · 1 · 18 hrs
Kris Cadogan
Kris Cadogan I guess I will see how things go on my own walk. Can’t be much worse I imagine.

Laurel J. Davis
Laurel J. Davis I’m so sorry for your hurt. Those are probably weak words to you right now, because you probably feel you need more than words, and not from other people but from God Himself. He seems not just silent but absent, as well. Just know, nothing is more final than what is truly ordained by God. So, when it seems all is lost, or that you are lost, meditate on Romans 8:28 through the end of the chapter. Nothing can separate you from God’s love, not even you. If He’s done nothing else for us, if He only ever answers just one prayer, praise His name it’s the most important thing. Namely, given us His only begotten Son to save us from the penalty of our sins, which is eternal torment in hell. Whatever “hell” you feel you’re enduring now, it can’t compare to what awaits the truly lost. Remember, the rich man thought just a drop of water from Lazarus’ finger would quench his fiery torment. You have salvation, and if that’s all you have, how blessed you still are indeed!

Like · Reply · 1 · 15 hrs
Gwen Sellers
Write a reply…
William Brenner
William Brenner Kris, I think most or all of us have been at lows such as this and feeling completely bottomed out. I can look back now and see how those times actually played a part in lifting me higher than I thought would ever be possible at a much later time. Was He teaching me patience so I could understand how He has been so patient with me and my doubts? Perhaps. But at least I now see cycles like this as normal and not to be dwelling much on how empty I felt at the time. It isn’t based on how we feel, or our moods, or even our circumstances. It’s based on the truth of His Word. When He promised you and me that no one can snatch us from His hands, you can totally trust Him. But the promise was not that we would always know He is there or that we would feel or see signs of His presence. No one has seen God, so how would we know what that should look like? We may see Him in the most unexpected ways if we see anything at all–and we may be looking into a huge desert, but know that He created every grain of sand and has an account of every one. He sees you this moment and He knows your struggles. The question is whether we can rise above them to see His struggles on behalf of each one of us. He experienced emptiness, loneliness, despair and exasperation. You are not exceptional in your feelings and thoughts. But you may be tested in these times to show you His way of baring your soul to empty oneself completely so you have nothing left but Him to rely upon. You are never alone, but you can choose to embrace every day as an opportunity to show that you are willing to share the agony that He has experienced for your sake and let the dark feelings fail to stop you from abandoning Him when it is a dark night in your soul.

Like · Reply · 3 · 18 hrs
Pstr Richard J Rizzi
Pstr Richard J Rizzi Praying for you, Kris.

Like · Reply · 3 · 18 hrs
Dwight Payne
Dwight Payne Kris, please know that God does care. He loves you and your GQ family loves you. We are all praying for you.

Like · Reply · 4 · 18 hrs
Lea Ann Davis McCombs
Lea Ann Davis McCombs Hi Kris. I can’t add much more to the heartfelt responses of your fellow believers, but my heart hurts for you. You’re the age of my son, and your letter mirrors greatly what he is going through as well. Tozer calls it the “dark night of the soul.” It’s horrible! Agonizing. Faith-ripping. When both of my parents died within 3 years of each other, young, healthy, servants of the Lord dying agonizing deaths from cancer, I was furious with a God that would let this happen. How could I love and worship a God who sits by while His children cry in pain? I began to realize that all I had clung to was a flimsy plastic version of the real God. He didn’t owe me an explanation. He owed me nothing. He is God and I am not. It took a few years to wrestle through it, like Jacob wrestled with the angel. So I understand that dark night of the soul. God understands it too. Just keep wrestling. It’s worth it. Life on the other side is beautiful and worth the fight. I’m a counselor and If I can help you, feel free to private message me any time. Your story is far from over, brother.

Like · Reply · 6 · 18 hrs
Gina Cook
Gina Cook My heart breaks for you. What a heavy burden you carry! Praying for you! Not sure what it is specifically in your life that is bringing you much pain, but do know you do not suffer alone. What a powerful passage of scripture Hebrews 11:36-40 that Tim shared above. Today’s “Christianity” is about having date nights with God and whispers of encouragement from Him on a daily basis as we sip our Starbucks coffee and skip through the fields in the best attire. Don’t buy into that, not that you are, but it’s worth saying because i know women that have been left to feel forgotten when God didn’t show up for them the way He seemed to show up for everyone else. That is a tactic from Satan to keep people thinking they must not be special or heard by God at all. I wonder if the women getting their head chopped off a few months ago while singing praises to Jesus were consumed with that sort of “Christianity,” I think not. In some of my darkest hours I always came to this conclusion eventually; my Christian actions do not give me any more worthiness than my sins would – This life is not about me – He has suffered more than I have – My hurt pales in comparison to my offenses towards Him.

Keep pouring out to God, don’t give up, don’t stop reading His Word and know you are being prayed for in a mighty way!

Like · Reply · 6 · 17 hrs · Edited
Corpuz Valdemor Avellaneda Ramil
Corpuz Valdemor Avellaneda Ramil Kris Cadogan you are not alone. I have experienced those before. And I fully understand you.

Like · Reply · 4 · 16 hrs
Mary Bennett Reetz
Mary Bennett Reetz I love you, Kris, and I’ll be praying. When we are weak, he is our strength. Have you listened to Dr. Stanley’s message about “When God is Silent?” I believe it is on YouTube.

Like · Reply · 4 · 16 hrs
Pstr Richard J Rizzi
Pstr Richard J Rizzi I just read this: if Jesus is all you have, Jesus is all you need.
The Word teaches He is all sufficient for all our needs.
Kris, I pray you will, at least, continue to seek the Lord because you and I need no miracles, no experiences or any test of man to know that He is God.
I believe that just placing your trust in Him is enough.

Like · Reply · 2 · 16 hrs · Edited
Corpuz Valdemor Avellaneda Ramil
Corpuz Valdemor Avellaneda Ramil GOD’S SOVEREIGNTY RULES MAN’S LIFE
by Loraine Boettner
Every thinking person readily sees that some sovereignty rules his life. He was not asked whether or not he would have existence; nor when, where, or what he would be born; whether in the twentiethSee More

Like · Reply · 2 · 15 hrs · Edited
Edie Pittard Edmondson
Edie Pittard Edmondson Kris, something you didn’t mention was really placed on my heart. You are laying everything on God, but you don’t mention Satan. The spiritual battle is real, and if you are missing Satan’s role in all this, Satan has you right where he wants you. It is not God who intends to destroy your faith, it is Satan. Satan is who comes to steal, kill and destroy. God wants us to have life and have it to the full.
I know waiting on Him is hard; sometimes it seems interminable. We are all with you because we have all been there in one way or another. We don’t (and can’t) understand His ways or His timing either. But we can say we know the fight is worth it. We can say we know what it’s like to go through periods where we lost more battles than we won. And though we may have forgotten it at times, we always came back to and relied on the fact that regardless of how we fared in the battle, the ultimate war has already been won. That’s the only reason we have lived to fight another day. And fight another day we have and we will continue to do so, because Satan will always try to make us ineffective in our witness. And so we keep fighting, and we get to know what it is like to come out of battles bloodied, but stronger. Not necessarily where we expected or wanted to be, but fully aware that we are where God wants us to be.
As Ed first said, it took courage to post what you’re going through. I pray you use that courage to keep fighting, only now identify the true enemy. Satan wants you to feel this way. Satan wants you defeated and believing God does not care for you. But know that you are never alone in any battle. Your brothers and sisters in Christ are ready to go into battle with you in any way we can. And even though you can’t always feel Him, God is with you too. He has never left you and will never leave you or forsake you. Don’t let Satan deceive you into believing otherwise.
All of the posts may seem overwhelming, but I pray you feel overwhelmed by our love for you in and through Christ. We are called to bear each other’s burdens. Please, don’t hesitate to reach out to any one of us. We are here for you.

Like · Reply · 3 · 15 hrs
Adam Davis
Adam Davis Kris, we’ve never met and I have never posted on here before, being relatively new to the group. For what it’s worth, I hope that you can see in some way that – even if you can’t be certain of very many things right now – you can see there are people here who care about you. They genuinely care about your life and your soul. If you have nothing else right now, you are not alone even if you feel that you are. Loneliness is the place where the enemy attacks with the most ferocity. By all means, please stay connected and keep talking. Even if it’s all negative right now. People will listen and continue listening.

You probably know all the intellectual responses to your concerns. You are aware of the trials in the lives of others, the trials of those persecuted in the early church and today. You’ve heard the harrowing stories of foreign missionaries. You’ve read a lot of books and know the “right” theological answers to your deepest issues.

But there is another aspect of our humanity that doesn’t always respond to the rational intellect. God gives us enough reasons to make believing and trusting him completely rational, but we cannot live by reason alone.

From what you said, it seems that you have probably been attending a church. My prayer is simply that you find the energy to seek pastoral care right now. There are people gifted by God for such work. You may think it’s futile. But in your post you seemed to imply you’ve exhausted all the options. Have you exhausted this one? Please consider this as you check off all the boxes

It may be of interest for you to know that I was encouraged by aspects of your post. Your resisting of temptation was great and a good testimony. The zeal with which you pursued your faith is admirable and a quality not found in 1 person in 1,000. That you worked with GQ for 11 months means that you impacted the lives of many on the other side of the questions. Have you thought about those you impacted who witnessed your walk for the past three years? You affirmed many Biblical truths, so I’m sure you know that many things you did were pleasing to the Lord. You also know that Jesus promised rewards to those who forsook all to follow Him.

Like · Reply · 6 · 15 hrs
Deb Whittier Newman
Deb Whittier Newman Totally agree.

Like · Reply · 1 · 15 hrs
Gwen Sellers

Write a reply…
 
Michael Karpf
Michael Karpf I have gone through this myself and 3 years ago I was contemplating suicide as I truly believed God would never act favorably in my life again. I am sorry to hear you are going through this and I am praying for you. There is light at the end of the tunnel, but I know how it feels when the only light you see is that of an oncoming freight train

Like · Reply · 6 · 15 hrs

Laurel J. Davis
Laurel J. Davis Michael, can you share how you came out of that very hard time? It might be helpful for Kris and others.

Like · Reply · 1 · 4 hrs · Edited
Michael Karpf
Michael Karpf I can, but it’s after 11PM in Bangkok. It might be better if I can share it by telling you instead of writing about it. Let me get back to you on this. Have a blessed night

Like · Reply · 1 · 4 hrs
Gwen Sellers

Write a reply…
 
Evan Plante
Evan Plante I’m sorry for your distress-in-the-Lord, Kris. (I’ll pray.) But God plays the “long game.” I’ve been at this Christianity stuff for 45 years…the majority of which involved sadness, disappointment… you know the stuff. Yet, there was a continuance… albeit, “Left foot, right foot.” All I can say is that maturing in Christ is a process, and sometimes the process feels like going through a wood-chipper. Take some time off, surely. But try to look way down the road…less inward and less around.

Like · Reply · 3 · 9 hrs
Kristi-Joy Matovich
Kristi-Joy Matovich Kris, thank you for having the courage to share here. I hope you find comfort.

Like · Reply · 1 · 4 hrs
Vera Rudolph
Vera Rudolph Apparently many of us are going through a period when God seems silent – even long-time Believers. But one thing I do know, we cannot walk away. He hold us in the palm of His Hand, He chose us – not we Him. Jesus Himself said in Luke 10:20 “rejoice because your names are written in Heaven” and that is in indelible ink.

Team GotQuestions Blog

a Blog for Sharing Stories, Tips & Encouragement